Scott Hollow Cave, Root Canal Passage

 
 Interesting Electronic Stuff Many Uses! 

Here is Plans for the LED Cave Light , Revised 11-20-01


Introduction

The LED cave light is a improvement over conventional incandescent lights. The light output is constant, and battery life is improved. LED's are also very rugged when compared to a fragile filament. There are some web pages that will say to the contary, but the results speak for themselves.
 

Building the LED cave lamp

Nathan Hirneisen, (cave_nate@hotmail.com)

The never ending trips to the store to buy batteries for caving lights was starting to become tiresome. I bet the greeter even knew my name, a sure sign that I been spending too much time in Wal-Mart. Living in Baltimore for the summer, I was deprived from caving activities, to keep sane I tried prototyping a new idea for a LED cave lamp.

What is a White LED

Unlike a regular incandescent lamp, a LED has no filament. The light is generated by a process called injection electroluminescence. This process is fairly complex, but the result is that a LED can generate "cold" light of a single color. To make a white LED, a blue LED die is coated with YAG phosphor. The phosphor converts the blue light into white like light. That is why the supposedly white LED looks so bluish in color. Most LEDs are self-focused with a built in lenses. Typical beam angles are 10-50 degrees, but take this spec with grain of salt. Most white LEDs seem to make a more diffused sort of light, not a sharp beam.

LEDs are somewhat finicky to operate. Unlike an incandescent light bulb that can be operated over a "wide" range of voltages, a LED needs a fairly constant voltage to operate. This is due to the exponential current-voltage curve of the device. A exponential current-voltage curve just means that if you put 3 volts across the LED you get .005 amps to flow, but if you just increase the voltage just by .5 volts to 3.5 volts, .025 amps will flow. That’s 5 times the current for just a .5 volt increase in voltage. Typically, white LEDs are rated for a max current of .03 amps. Note: the light output is almost directly proportional to the current through the bulb.

Luminous efficiency is a measure of how well a device converts electrical power to light. A higher number for luminous efficiency is better. Some typical values are 10 lumens/watt for a small incandescent bulb, 15 lumens/watt for a small halogen bulb, and 50 lumens/watt for a compact florescent lamp.

From tests that Nevin Davis conducted it was found that the Hosfeld 25-363 with a 20 deg beam had a luminous efficiency about 11 lumens/watt @ 20 mA. This number is low for an LED, but due to the narrow beam angle the light seems bright. I hypothesized that this low value is due to greater losses in the lenses as the beam angle is made narrower. For comparison, the Nichia NSPW510BS has a luminous efficiency double that of the Hosfeld LED at the same current, but the Nichia LED has a beam angle of 50 degrees. The Hosfeld 25-363 is the LED used in this project. Another LED that was tested by Nevin was the Nichia NSPW510BS. The specs follow:

Current mA

Current mA

Voltage V

Power, Watts

Luminous Flux ,Lumens

Luminous efficiency, Lumens/Watt

Peak Illuminance at 20cm, Lux

5

3.085

0.015

0.455

29.48

29.48

18.17

10

3.218

0.032

0.906

28.17

28.17

31.67

15

3.318

0.049

1.28

25.72

25.72

45.5

20

3.4

0.068

1.61

23.74

23.74

54.17

25

3.45

0.086

1.92

22.3

22.3

66.67

(opps! extra Luminous efficiency col),These numbers show some interesting trends. The LED is more efficient for lower current, but the tradeoff is less illuminance. This means for a more efficient, longer lasting light more LEDs are needed for the same light output.

I did some quick back of the envelope calculations and found for someone who builds a "super efficient" lamp with 33 LEDs compared to a "regular" lamp with 9 LEDs, one would have to cave for over 1000 hours during the life time of the lamp to recoup the cost of the extra LEDs. This is about 300 typical cave trips (for me). Or 60 cave trips a year if I assume a 5-year lifetime of the cave light. (Not saying that the light will be bad in 5 years, but assuming some thing better will replace it in 5 years). That’s a lot of caving! This assumes disposable battery operation. Both lights provide about the same amount of peak illuminance, but the more efficient light lasts about 30% longer than the regular light.

First LED light method, Current Limiting Resistor

. For battery operation using 3 AA cells in series, (like a Zoom), you have 4.5 volts. Connecting a LED directly to 3 cells in series will burn it out instantly. One way to overcome this is to add a linear element to the circuit. All this means is to add a resistor in series with the LED. The resistor limits the current to the LED so it don’t burn out. However, this adds 2 drawbacks. One is as the batteries die down the LED will dim quickly. The other limitation is that the resistor dissipates power and makes the circuit inefficient. For example, with a white LED connected in series with a 47-ohm resistor with 3 AA batteries supplying the power, 35% of the power would be lost in the resistor.

I don’t want to down play this method of powering an LED too much though. It has the advantage that is very simple, (K.I.S.S.), and it is easy to make.

Below is a diagram on how to connect this all up. The ambitious could then carefully smash an old burnt out lamp and solder this circuit directly to the lamp base. This would allow someone to use an existing headlamp setup with no modifications. However, one must be careful to get the wiring right. LEDs are polarity sensitive. When you look at the LED, note that one lead is longer than the other one. This longer wire is connected to the positive side of the circuit. Chances are that the wiring in the donor headlamp is reversed. If so pry out the AA adaptor in the battery compartment and reverse the 2 press on terminals that connect to the battery pack if the light don’t work.

Since one LED alone is too dim by its self, connect at least 3 or more of the LED/ resistor setups in parallel to one power source. When wiring this to a lamp base, the wiring will get tight, but it should still be doable.

With 3 LEDs the light should stay on for about 30 hours. I heard of some 3 LED lamps that say that they will stay on for 45+ hours. The light would be so dim at the end that you could hardly see anything, but that is better than no light! As you add more LEDs the time the light stays on is approximately equal to: (hours with 3 AA alkaline batteries, for this and similar circuits only).

 

Parts List

- Lamp base to fit 3 cell lamp like Petzl Zoom, Mega, etc

- 47 ohm, ¼ watt resistor, (get at radio shack), you get 5 for a buck

- White LED (Order from Hosfelt Electronics (800-524-6464), pn 25-363, cost $3.75 each)

NOTE: with these given parts a 3 cell lamp MUST be used, else the LED will burn out. If one would like to use a 4 cell lamp the resistance would need to be increased to 120 ohms.

Method Two, Switched Mode Boost Regulator

The LED light using method 2 in use

As mentioned before, the disadvantage of using the current limiting resistor is that light output varies as battery voltage changes, and it is inefficient. Now imagine that there was a battery that had constant voltage of 3.5 volts for its entire life. One could just connect this battery directly to the LED with no power robbing current limiting resistor. This same thing can be accomplished via a voltage conversion circuit. For this circuit, a boost converter topology with a Maxim max1771 control circuit is used.

A boost converter circuit changes a varying lower voltage, (a battery pack), to a regulated higher voltage, (which goes to the LEDs). This is accomplished in two (simplified) steps. The first step is to pump a inductor with current from the power source. The second step is to try to "turn off" the current in the inductor. Due to the nature of a inductor, it wants to try to keep the current going even if it was turned off, (like a flywheel). So to compensate for this, the inductor increases its voltage in an attempt to keep the current going. This increase in voltage is then transferred to the output of the circuit. By varying the ratio of inductor on time to inductor off time the output voltage can be changed, (this is called the duty cycle) The Maxim integrated circuit controls the duty cycle and ensures that the output voltage stays constant (within +- 1% ideally).

A short circuit description: the components in the box on the circuit diagram marked "keep wires in box as short as possible" are the actual boost voltage conversion circuit. The rest of the circuit is the controller for the boost voltage conversion circuit. Note that there are two feedback mechanisms in the circuit. The first one is the usual voltage feedback, which controls the output voltage. The second one is an averaged output current feedback. The current is sensed in R1. The reason for the averaged output current feedback is to ensure that the LEDs are not burnt out due to too much current. The circuit has no protection for the LEDs other than this, and there is a chance that due to component aging and temperature variations in the circuit that the LEDs might be over stressed with out it.

The power inductor value that is suggested in the Max 1771 data sheet (22uH) is too small in value for a 9 LED load. This makes the circuit operate in discontinues conduction mode. The consequence of this is that the circuit has higher than necessary inductor currents, which lead to greater resistive power losses in the Mosfet and inductor. I found that 150 to 100 uH seemed to give the best performance. There is a section in the Mohan text, listed in the reference section that gives formulas to figure this all out. The key to applying the formulas is to assume the worst case scenario. Note: if more LEDs are added to the circuit the inductor value can be reduced.

The efficiency of this boost regulator varies somewhat with varying input voltages, but in general it is about 94% efficient for fresh batteries, and about 70% efficient with dead batteries (for 4 AA alkaline batteries). With 3 AA alkaline batteries the efficiency was 94% with new batteries, and with 2 new batteries the efficiency was 68%. By the way, the circuit will operate with 2 to 6 AA batteries for the power. With more batteries the light will last longer.

Looking at the numbers one would ask what was gained with the complex boost regulator. The biggest advantage is that the circuit will extract the last bit of life out of every battery. Where as with a normal incandescent lamp the batteries must be thrown out when the individual cell voltage is about 1.2 volts, the boost regulator will function with individual cell voltages as low as .5 volts. This allows one to use the batteries longer with no noticeable degradation in light output. Testing the actual circuit with 9 LEDs, and 4 AA Duracell batteries, (which were a year after their use by date) the lamp was lit at 100% brightness for 23 hours; the last 2 hours the light dimmed somewhat since the input voltage was so low (.88 volts). This is since loses in the circuit are inversely proportional to input voltage. As a side note, the circuit will not turn on with total battery voltages below 2.5 volts, but once the circuit is turned on it will operate with battery voltages below 1 volt.

Building the circuit

The key to building this circuit is sort and direct wiring of the components and proper component selection (just use parts from parts list). The circuit board listed in the parts list is fairly small. If the circuit is built on this same pref-board, the wiring lengths should work out fine. Connect the wires as listed on the schematic diagram, paying special attention to the connection lengths of the wires between the Mosfet, capacitors, the diode, and the inductor. I attached the circuit board to the lamp housing with RTV silicon. This works, but makes future modifications a little tough. The ambitious might figure out a better way. After connecting the circuit, there is one adjustment to be made. Using a voltmeter, measure the voltage across the bank of LEDs. It should be 10.5 volts. If it is not, turn the screw on R4 until it is. Actually it would be better to measure the output current when making this adjustment (75 mA), but that is a little tougher.

To house the circuit an el-cheapo Rayovac headlamp from Wal-Mart was used. The regular incandescent lamp was ripped out and a circuit board with the LED lamp was inserted in its place. Leave the original on-off switch in the headlamp, use it to turn the new LED circuit on and off. It is important that when soldering the components into the circuit board that the corners of the board are left free. This is since you must nibble the corners of the circuit board off to make the light fit in the lamp housing.

The wire that connects the battery pack to the lamp on the Rayovac headlight is too short to put on a helmet, so disconnect the original wires at the battery pack end, and remove the plug at the light end. Take a piece of lamp cord and solder this in, in place of the original wire. In addition, epoxy in the wire at both ends where the wire passes through the housing, this will provide strain relief, and make sure no water gets in. Some epoxy’s don’t stick well to certain plastics so make sure to test the strain relief operation before using the light. A good idea is to make a knot in each end of the wire so a epoxy failure won’t allow the wires to rip out.

Since the LEDs vary some in their individual voltage characteristics, it is best to match each series LED string. Connect each LED in series with a 1000 ohm resistor, and connect this to a 9 volt power supply. With a voltmeter measure the voltage drop across the LED. Some LEDs will have a slightly higher voltage drop, some lower. What you want to do is equalize each of the series LED strings so that the total voltage drop is about the same for each string. Eg, if one LED has a lower voltage drop, and another has a higher voltage drop and another LED’s voltage drop is in the middle you would put all these LEDs in one series string so that the voltage drop is equalized with the 2 other strings.

Some improvement that would make this circuit better would be more LEDs. The circuit can drive 30 LEDs with no problems, but it would be awfully expensive to build It would be $112 just for LEDs. 20 LEDs might be a better compromise. The circuit now is set up to operate with 3 parallel strings of 3 LEDs in series. The circuit might be a little more efficient if instead there were 5 parallel strings of 2 LEDs in series. However, this change would necessitate that the output voltage be change from 10.5 to 7 volts. To do this the resistor network consisting of R2, R3, and R4 would need to be re calculated. Also, the current sensing resistor, R1, would need to be changed. Better mechanical lay out and interfacing to the light are some other areas to improve on.

Note: I have been using this light for over a year with no problems. One time while doing a sump the internals of the light got wet, but the circuit still worked. ROBUST ! In the next version I would most likly pot the circuit in silicon so if the housing leaks the circuit don't get wet.

The Circuit Diagram

 

 

 

Parts List

Part

Description

Supplier

Supplier pn

cost for quantity needed

C1, C2

47 mfd, 25 volt capacitor

Digi-Key

P6711

$2

 

C3, C4

.1 mfd, 50 volt capacitor

Radio Shack

.5

D1

Schottky diode

Digi-Key

11DQ04

0.38

 

Q1

Logic level n-Mosfet

Digi-Key

IRLZ24

1.32

 

R1

1.6 ohm resistor

Digi-Key

P1.6W-1BK

0.25

 

R2

66,000 ohm resistor

Radio Shack

 

 1

 

R3

10,000 ohm resistor

Radio Shack

 

 1

 

R4

1000 ohm variable resistor

Radio Shack

 

 1

 

LEDs

white pre-focused

Hosfett

25-363

 3.75 x 9 = 33.75

 

L1

150uH power inductor

Digi-Key

 M5920

3.82

 

 

pref-board, 1.75" x 1.75"

Radio Shack

276-148

2

 

Rayovac Headlamp

Wal-Mart

SPHLT4AA

9.97

U1

Maxim max1771 PWM controller

Digi-Key

MAX1771CPA

4.08

 

Total cost = $61.07 +misc parts

Parts Suppliers

Hosfelt Electronics 800 524 6464

Digi-Key Electronics 800 344 4539

References

Mohan, Undeland, and Robbins, "Power Electronics", Wiley Inc, pp 172-177

Nevin W. Davis, "AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE FEASIBILITY OF DESIGNING A "REAL" CAVE LAMP USING WHITE LEDS" contact author, (a grotto member), for availability

Agilent Technologies, HLMP-CW15, (Data sheet for white LEDs), http://www.semiconductor.agilent.com/led_lamps/hlmpcw15.html

Maxim Integrated Products, max1771 data sheet, http://dbserv.maxim-ic.com/quick_view2.cfm?pdf_num=1030

Rayovac Corp, "Application Notes and Product Data Sheet", http://www.rayovac.com/

Thanks to Nevin Davis for his Technical Assistance

As a post-script the price of the LEDs went down to $2.99.


Useful Links
CREG
Radio Location Methods
NSS Homepage
Go Penn State!
PA Cave Conservancy
Power Electronic Soc.
.
Copyright Notice: Commercial use is prohibited without express written authorization from Nathan Hirneisen. Blah Blah Blah.....(like in Peanuts)
  Page Created and Copyright (c) Nathan Hirneisen, Aug 2001